When Kosas (you probably know them as the makers of the obsession-worthy Wet Lip Oil Gloss and Tinted Face Oil) launched a new concealer last February, we couldn’t wait to try it out. But rather than having just one editor test the Revealer Concealer, we decided to have ten women see how it measured up to their go-to concealer. And the buttery medium-to-full coverage, skin-improving formula did not disappoint.
So when we heard that the clean beauty brand launched 12 new shades of the now-best-selling product this month, we were pretty pumped. With the new additions, Revealer Concealer is now available in 28 different hues compatible with a variety of different skin colors and undertones. And if you’re not sure which one is right for you, Kosas’s shade finder quiz can help you narrow down the options. Not totally sold yet? Here, check out the honest thoughts (and un-retouched photos) of the women who tried it.
Tested By: Dena S.
Usual Concealer: Hourglass Vanish Airbrush Concealer
“I recently bought the new Hourglass Vanish Airbrush Concealer and so far I’ve been loving it. My only qualm? It takes quite some time to blend in. This Kosas formula totally fixes that problem—it blends like a dream whether I apply it with a Beauty Blender or a concealer brush for my under eyes and the red areas around my nose. While the Kosas concealer tends to crease right after application (especially under the eyes), I just reblend it with a Q-tip and I’m good to go. It’s also a little bit shiny right after application, so I tend to mattify it with a touch of powder.”
Tested By: Brianna L.
Usual Concealer: Supergoop! Bright-Eyed 100% Mineral Eye Cream SPF 40
“Every other concealer I’ve tried is either too intense for my otherwise natural everyday makeup, or creases and makes my under-eye lines more obvious. Kosas has changed the game for me. I swiped the super fluffy doe foot brush under my eyes and dotted it on a few blemishes before blending with a damp Beauty Blender and I was like, Where has this been my whole life? It’s creamy, super blendable and I only noticed slight creasing, which I was able to fix easily. I’ve been thoroughly enjoying putting it on every morning and love that it’s made with clean ingredients.”
Tested By: Emily L.
Usual Concealer: Armani Power Fabric Concealer
“On a scale of one to ten, I’m giving Kosas a 7.8. The consistency is close to Tarte Shape Tape, which I’ve used in the past, as it goes on pretty thick. I use concealer under my eyes and found I only needed a little to get the coverage I was looking for. I will probably keep using Armani Power Fabric Concealer, because it feels light but offers a lot of coverage. I could totally see myself adding a light layer of Kosas when I need a bit more coverage.”
Tested By: Chelsea C.
Usual Concealer: Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Pro Filt’r Instant Retouch Concealer
“I’m just starting to use makeup more, and concealer has been my new favorite product. The concealer I’m using at the moment is from Fenty, but this new Kosas one gives it some major competition. It blended well with my skin tone and it doesn’t feel dry at all. I used some setting powder, but I think even without it, my under eye wouldn’t feel cakey or dry.”
Tested By: Victoria V.
Usual Concealer: Maybelline Age Rewind Eraser Dark Circle Treatment Concealer
“Although way more full coverage than my go-to (Maybelline Age Rewind), the Kosas concealer still felt surprisingly lightweight and lasted on my skin much longer than I’m used to. It oxidized a bit after it dried, slowly turning the color a little darker than my skin tone, so just be extra cautious while picking your shade.”
Tested By: Brynn C.
Usual Concealer: IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Full Coverage Anti-Aging Waterproof Concealer
“My go-to brand was IT Cosmetics, which is basically glue you can put under your eyes. It always got the job done but was way heavier than I prefer for my day-to-day. The Kosas concealer is lightweight, stayed on all day long and didn’t crease at all. It’s definitely my new favorite.”
Tested By: Zarina M.
Usual Concealer: NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer
“The Kosas concealer was great—it blended perfectly without looking too thick under my eyes. The color was nearly perfect for my skin tone, but I might even go a little lighter next time to brighten up my dark circles. It does come off a bit shiny at first, but dusting translucent powder over top does the trick. I typically use NARS, but this Kosas formula is a nice consistency that felt pretty similar.”
Tested By: Idara A.
Usual Concealer: Too Faced Born This Way Naturally Radiant Concealer
“This concealer has a very silky and smooth texture; it kind of reminds me of NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer with how dewy it is, which I love! I didn’t get as much coverage as I do with my go-to Too Faced Born This Way concealer, so I had to build and build until I got the coverage I wanted.”
Tested By: Angie M.
Usual Concealer: NYX Professional Makeup Can’t Stop Won’t Stop Concealer
“I LOVE this Kosas concealer. Shade 07 was perfect for my skin tone, it really brightened up my under eyes and lasted all night long. I usually use NYX concealer, but I don’t think I can ever go back after trying Kosas.”
Tested By: Cylla S.
Usual Concealer: CoverGirl TruBlend Undercover Concealer
“I really loved using this concealer! It has a very soft and smooth texture and blended very nicely with my skin. It even lasted throughout the day when I had to travel around the city. I mainly use CoverGirl or whatever quick product I can find, but I definitely plan to keep using this one in the future.”
PureWow may receive a portion of sales from products purchased from this article, which was created independently from PureWow’s editorial and sales departments.